Quote from: eska on Today at 06:15:28 PMClosed and hooded up ankle-length djellebah. All mdesc is gone.

Which would be fine, IMO. My issue with mdesc-hiding masks is that the description is -replaced- with the mdesc of the mask. So the green-eyed barrel-chested man, wearing the mask, appears to be a purple tregil with floppy ears, complete with a 6-line description of his smooth skin and tail.

That's why -masks- specifically - are a bad idea.  If the mask resulted in
The masked humanoid

and look masked returned

This person is disguised from the neck up to look like a purple, floppy-eared tregil. His shoulders are narrow, he has a barrel chest and long limbs. His left hand is missing a pinky and he has big feet with delicate ankles.

If that happened, then masks would work great. But that's not what happens, and that's why masks don't work.

Would be 100% fine with someone wearing an ankle-length cloak/cape, head covering, face covering, and gloves, to show "the tall humanoid" and an mdesc that says:

This humanoid is covered head to toe, it's impossible to see beyond their attire.

I can only hope the sponsored roles go to the people with a proven history of being able to play them, with the best ideas and the most coverage from their intended staffers.

We all took our balls and went home, because the game closed. It doesn't matter when.

At the risk of being controversial, will we resort to handing out roles to the same old people as before? I am speaking of the same people who, because they didn't like the fact that seasons was going to be a thing, decided to take their ball and go home?

There were a few die hards trying to keep it going until the bitter end.

Quote from: Riev on Today at 07:53:52 PMUnless its just easier to type "kill riev" than it is to "ooc consent for torture"

kill riev

Hmm - yeah that's pretty easy.

I really think the jump start rules are going to make for amazing changes in some of this.  Something about grinding for endless hours to get your skills to a certain level can sometimes make you feel like you have to use those skills.  Being competent with less time involved feels like its going to really shift things toward story telling.  Hope so anyhow.

Quote from: Dresan on Today at 01:45:29 PMConflict is better promoted with autonomy of regions, allowing people to work as a villain in one place while being a saint in the other.

This is in direct conflict with one of the stated goals of the seasons, in that the playerbase is going to be more focused in a central location. And anyways, why not both? Being able to do something secretively in the place you live is important.

QuoteIf done incorrectly it has the potential to prevent meaningful RP because its harder to hold people accountable for their day to day behavior due to the fact they can become anonymous/someone new whenever the heck they want. It will lead to pure foolishness.

Again, having played multiple RPIs with desc obscuring ability, it really won't. It's not something that just leads to pure foolishness because there's a lot of PC-PC regulation.  PCs are not really able to do more crimes codedly than they could otherwise do with near invis stealth and maxed subterfuge skills. Plus, maybe at the hoity toity bar the guard screens for masks/hoods, makes people remove them, etc.

 Do you have an example of exactly what you worry is going to happen? Like your clan mate is gonna show up wearing a mask and rob you and you won't have any idea? I mean that, to me, just sounds like conflict/plot. Maybe you should be worried that the person skulking around you has the exact same build and boots as your newly hired hunter.

Quote from: Athapaxis on Today at 07:49:50 PMWe need to be more like the Count of Monte Cristo.  He wasn't just satisfied to kill his enemies.  He wanted to ruin them.  That's way more fun.

This is what I mean by changing the player perspective a little, because it still sits far too much on the side of "I need to kill people to avoid trouble down the road".

Burn your enemies. Break their legs. Cause temporary but debilitating injuries. Take a finger, disfigure an ear. We have a Consent file for far more than just "hey wanna sex". Its there for the brutality and gruesome nature of torture.

Unless its just easier to type "kill riev" than it is to "ooc consent for torture"

Not related to the masks but back to the PK discussion...   I once had a Templar light the side of my head on fire.  It was terrifying - it was traumatizing to my character - because it hurt and it affronted her dignity - and it set her on a whole new course of life that wound up being awesome.   It was still brutal. It still got my heart racing IRL.   

We need to be more like the Count of Monte Cristo.  He wasn't just satisfied to kill his enemies.  He wanted to ruin them.  That's way more fun.

Quote from: Halaster on Today at 07:09:53 PMMaybe (and this is just me theorycrafting, no promises or commitments) if it was a mask + a longcloak + hood up then it hides the mdesc.

Well, you're the one who can make that happen, and I think you should.

Quote from: Cowboy on Today at 04:44:25 PMI have found the single reroll and prioritizing stats are every useful to avoid such disappointments.  The new stat improvements will help too.  I avoid backgrounds and descriptions that paint me into a corner with the character.  The strongest elf alive?  The most agile dwarf in the Known?  The greatest swordsman to grace the Nak on 75 years?  What type of characters are you speaking of...fighters, raiders and enforcers that have massive strength, incredible agility, 125 hp and maxed wisdom because of a touched subclass?  Or the other way...you want a character with very poor agility and wisdom? The clumsy, dumb gladiator? 

I completely agree that the reroll (and reroll undo) and prioritization give us more control over stats than ever. They mitigate the randomness, and I hope that trend away from randomness continues in other ways.

To clarify, I didn't mean that concepts are rendered unplayable with bad stats. If a concept truly requires outstanding stats of some kind, that should be a special app. Having said that, the disappointment some people feel when getting meh stats with a combat role is understandable. And I don't want people to start out already feeling disappointed because they came up short in the stats lottery.

Yeah I don't think a mask alone is 'enough'.  Maybe (and this is just me theorycrafting, no promises or commitments) if it was a mask + a longcloak + hood up then it hides the mdesc.  Or something like that, where it's a combo of items that "make sense".