Extended Subguilds - Feedback sought

[Xeran Van Houten]

From my experience, the crafting ones really need the value skill - even if just capped at apprentice. In some cases it can be really hindering not to be able to see where the workmanship came from.

[Twilight]

I left it out from builder because...you can't value a building to see who made it anyways.

And to give a drawback.

[Xeran Van Houten]

I'm referring to the existing ones - not suggested ones that are not already in the game.

[Bushranger]

From my experience, the crafting ones really need the value skill - even if just capped at apprentice. In some cases it can be really hindering not to be able to see where the workmanship came from.

Supposedly Analyze does this, that's what staff keep telling me, so the crafting subguilds should be able to determine where the things they craft are from.

I want Master Trader to have the value skills. They don't craft anything so Analyze doesn't work for them and they're supposed to be able to trade in a range of goods but they need to rely on the players experience for estimating market price. I made a more vague reference to this at the beginning of the thread but I can see now most people just want to say plainly what skills they think are missing from subguilds.

[Adhira]

I'm going to lock this one now.  If you have more suggestions or comments please feel free to send those through to me in a request.

We're getting too deep in the skill detail here for it to stay on the discussion board.  The feedback has been useful and there are some good suggestions in here, so thanks for that.  We'll be looking at this over the next month or so and adjusting as we decide appropriate.