Armageddon General Discussion Board

General => Player Announcements and Collaboration => Topic started by: Dusky on March 21, 2008, 12:29:27 PM

Title: You know what I want?
Post by: Dusky on March 21, 2008, 12:29:27 PM
I want more PC slavers requesting generic slave characters whose fate will be uncertain but are likely to include being sold to some other group.  Oh, how I long to play a slave whose "position" or "job" or "duties" were completely at the whim of his masters, the group of rough slavers or whatever.  Did I app a merchant and you sold me as a warrior - tough luck to the purchaser.  Did I app a merchant and you have me scrubbing floors and hauling bricks?  Too bad for my character. Such is the crappy life of a slave.
Title: Re: You know what I want?
Post by: Tisiphone on March 21, 2008, 01:31:29 PM
Quote from: Dusky on March 21, 2008, 12:29:27 PM
I want more PC slavers requesting generic slave characters whose fate will be uncertain but are likely to include being sold to some other group.  Oh, how I long to play a slave whose "position" or "job" or "duties" were completely at the whim of his masters, the group of rough slavers or whatever.  Did I app a merchant and you sold me as a warrior - tough luck to the purchaser.  Did I app a merchant and you have me scrubbing floors and hauling bricks?  Too bad for my character. Such is the crappy life of a slave.


Start a slaver group that abducts people from the wastes.
I would play in your organisation so fast it'd make your head spin. In fact, I have plans for one myself, but my characters thus far haven't been in the right position to start it.

Wait...maybe this one could...hmm.
Title: Re: You know what I want?
Post by: spicemustflow on March 26, 2008, 10:51:27 PM
QuoteStart a slaver group that abducts people from the wastes.

That's an extremely cool idea, and I was thinking about it. Do you think it could work on the PCs, though?
Title: Re: You know what I want?
Post by: Tisiphone on March 26, 2008, 10:55:04 PM
YES.

That's the -point-, friend.

I don't mean to jump all over you, but this is an idea that excites me for all kinds of reasons.
Title: Re: You know what I want?
Post by: roughneck on March 26, 2008, 11:11:01 PM
Four or five years ago I played a mul in Borsail and the noble at the time was trying to get it going.  We grabbed up a few neat trophy creatures and then actually enslaved a PC we found in the wastes with this big mother cage our HG carried out.  It was a looong time ago but I do remember the PC didn't appreciate it and suicided after we brought him back.
Title: Re: You know what I want?
Post by: Rindan on March 26, 2008, 11:29:28 PM
Meh, so long as you are OOCly responsible for your slaves, other PCs have nothing to complain about.  If someone decides they don't want to be a slave and suicide, that is certainly their choice and you can't hold it against them.  That said, if you manage to enslave someone, you also could  have flat out killed them.  Better to enslave someone and let them decide if they want to play through it, rather than just flat out killing someone.  I know I sure as hell would pick slavery both OOCly and ICly over being killed for my trinkets.

The important thing you need to do though is to make sure that you are OOCly responsible for your slave.  It is one thing to take on a slave and give them lots of interesting things to do.  It is another entirely to take on a slave and then bore them to death.
Title: Re: You know what I want?
Post by: Tisiphone on March 26, 2008, 11:30:19 PM
Plus, abduction != slavery
Title: Re: You know what I want?
Post by: Yam on March 27, 2008, 12:04:57 AM
Yeah. I'm pretty sure the staff have said that going out and enslaving PC's is not kosher.
Title: Re: You know what I want?
Post by: Tisiphone on March 27, 2008, 12:10:26 AM
Quote from: Yam on March 27, 2008, 12:04:57 AM
Yeah. I'm pretty sure the staff have said that going out and enslaving PC's is not kosher.

Good thing I'm not jewish, then.


Knew that was going to happen sooner or later...
Title: Re: You know what I want?
Post by: Teal on March 27, 2008, 12:34:32 AM
Quote from: Tisiphone on March 27, 2008, 12:10:26 AM
Quote from: Yam on March 27, 2008, 12:04:57 AM
Yeah. I'm pretty sure the staff have said that going out and enslaving PC's is not kosher.

Good thing I'm not jewish, then.


Knew that was going to happen sooner or later...

Haha. Ahem.

I think going out an abuducting PCs for slaves sounds fun, weather you're the abductor or abductee. I could see where it would be a pain if you wanted to play a special role, and got hijacked from that. On the other hand, this IS Zalanthas, and what -does- go as you want it to? I think it's a fine thing to happen. It provides oppertunity for LOTS of interesting RP, from the abduction planning and execution of the abduction plan, to the selling of said PC, jobs of said PC, and possibly attempeted rescue and reprecussions from parties angered by the abduction of said PC.

But, ultimately, what staff says goes. Because I can only chip in my 2 'sid, and they OWN THE MARKET! Bwahaha! Ahem. Have staff actually said this? Or do we just think they did?
Title: Re: You know what I want?
Post by: Ladyimp on March 27, 2008, 12:46:30 AM
Something like a PC group of slavers sounds totally appropriate to me.  Yet another thing to surprise the heck out of a lone traveler - the quick, the dead, and those that travel in fearsomely large groups.

Heh, can see all kinds of ways to play around with this, and sure, suicide's one of the answers.

But anything from rolling with the new situation to waying anyone you know who might help you (who knows what might happen with that, from your powerful 'friend' purchasing you with great amusement as their own slave to a band of mercenaries paid to head out and fight to take you back... hrm, kidnapping the conscious in a telepathic society has interesting twists, thinking about it) to so -many- other ways to play as the victim in that sort of role....


Don't think I'd be in a rush to roll up a character to join that band, no... though I might.  Do think if I found myself in that sort of situation interacting with that band as a victim... good and intense rp ahead, so I'm hanging onto my keyboard.  And for me, would be only IC horrors or pressures causing a suicide attempt if there was one.  Loads of other answers, unless pushed so savagely to that point.
Title: Re: You know what I want?
Post by: Salt Merchant on March 27, 2008, 02:56:33 AM
Quote from: Ladyimp on March 27, 2008, 12:46:30 AM
Something like a PC group of slavers sounds totally appropriate to me.  Yet another thing to surprise the heck out of a lone traveler - the quick, the dead, and those that travel in fearsomely large groups.

How would it work, though, without NPC buyers? If the group got too good at its job, you could end up with half the PC population enslaved and a market for only a few of them.

A group that kidnaps and ransoms people, and that only sells them off as slaves or kills them if they can't get a decent ransom, might do well.
Title: Re: You know what I want?
Post by: Ghost on March 27, 2008, 03:02:35 AM
Not practical, since enslaving PCs is not legit.

A raider group (for the sake of raiding only) would work fine though
Title: Re: You know what I want?
Post by: a strange shadow on March 27, 2008, 03:13:25 AM
Killing PCs is okay, but enslaving them is not?

I don't really get it.
Title: Re: You know what I want?
Post by: Yam on March 27, 2008, 03:21:09 AM
It's an old "rule" I cannot find evidence of but cleanly remember.
Title: Re: You know what I want?
Post by: Ghost on March 27, 2008, 03:42:17 AM
Well if you kill they will make a new character and the life will go on.

Enslaving someone is not always a closure.  If you enslave, and they are the kind of people who can't store characters (some people bear through what I can literally call "pain" of getting bored to death just because they hate storing) you will be restricting them a great deal.

Plus, enslaving someone will certainly require a heavy work on the slaver.  They will have to find something to keep the slaves' players enjoy the game somehow, which is more likely to be not-fullfilled by the slaver properly.

I am not really defending this "rule" to be honest, but I don't really think it is an inapropriate rule either.  It is not really killing something major from the game world in my opinion.  And if enslaving the PC's will be allowed, I am not against it but I would prefer to see some guidelines/special rules for slaving PCs.
Title: Re: You know what I want?
Post by: LittleLostThief on March 27, 2008, 04:03:25 AM
Everyone plays to have fun.  The general consensus is that getting enslaved against your will kills that fun.

Dying is part of the game, and something that you can't really argue with.  Being forced to play something you don't want to apparently crosses a line.

Would you like it if I apped a character for you, down to the starting location, and forced you to play it?  Probably not.

Is it a little unrealistic?  Just a tad.  As a slaver though, you might be able to get away with "OOC:  Consent to being enslaved?", and if they say no, kill them instead.  After all, they were pretty weak, malnourished, and their teeth were obviously rotting out.  They wouldn't have made good slaves anyway.

Playing a slave isn't always that much fun anyway.  It always comes down to needing to be on when your master is, at least sometimes, and that isn't always possible.  Being randomly sold IC'ly to the highest bidder might not exactly facilitate that kind of relationship.
Title: Re: You know what I want?
Post by: Xio on March 27, 2008, 04:19:02 AM
Shoot I wish I could play a slave. I've tried a few times to get into slaves roles only to get shot down with the 'We fear it will be to constricting and simply boring for you' I understand and accept such concerns. Though, a bored slave is usually a rebellious slave. Give your slave a second to think and that's second enough to plan a way to get out that window. Never said I'd stick around if it got boring :) Can come hunt me down, I'll enjoy the flee and hide RP. Two minutes away is enough to gut yourself. Any slave, any slave, can commit suicide. Often the simplest way is to say no. I don't see enslaving as being restricting. If you abduct someone, lock them behind a door and never come back, that is no where near slavery and is completely pointless. If you were going to kill me anyway, I'd love the chance for some slave Rp. Or, at least the chance to escape with my life and be hunted down. Perhaps you'll never find me and my char will walk into a mek, or I'll get caught and stabbed in the back. Never know, could lead a prosperous life and enslave you.
Title: Re: You know what I want?
Post by: Ghost on March 27, 2008, 09:37:09 AM
Quote from: Xio on March 27, 2008, 04:19:02 AM
Shoot I wish I could play a slave. I've tried a few times to get into slaves roles only to get shot down with the 'We fear it will be to constricting and simply boring for you' I understand and accept such concerns.

I believe you can special app if it is something you want to play.
Title: Re: You know what I want?
Post by: Tisiphone on March 27, 2008, 09:39:08 AM
Or collaborate with another player.
Title: Re: You know what I want?
Post by: Xio on March 27, 2008, 10:29:29 AM
Quote from: Ghost on March 27, 2008, 09:37:09 AM
Quote from: Xio on March 27, 2008, 04:19:02 AM
Shoot I wish I could play a slave. I've tried a few times to get into slaves roles only to get shot down with the 'We fear it will be to constricting and simply boring for you' I understand and accept such concerns.

I believe you can special app if it is something you want to play.

I've tried spec apps. That's what I've been told. Never spec apped when they were LOOKING for slaves is my problem I think. Randomly asking for a slave or gladiator is a no-no apparently *shrugs* and I'm always deep in a char when they're looking. Don't wanna spec app and tie up that slave slot if by some wild chance my char lives past his next meal.
Title: Re: You know what I want?
Post by: Tarx on March 27, 2008, 10:40:46 AM
Quote from: Xio on March 27, 2008, 04:19:02 AM
Shoot I wish I could play a slave. I've tried a few times to get into slaves roles only to get shot down with the 'We fear it will be to constricting and simply boring for you' I understand and accept such concerns. Though, a bored slave is usually a rebellious slave. Give your slave a second to think and that's second enough to plan a way to get out that window. Never said I'd stick around if it got boring :) Can come hunt me down, I'll enjoy the flee and hide RP. Two minutes away is enough to gut yourself. Any slave, any slave, can commit suicide. Often the simplest way is to say no. I don't see enslaving as being restricting. If you abduct someone, lock them behind a door and never come back, that is no where near slavery and is completely pointless. If you were going to kill me anyway, I'd love the chance for some slave Rp. Or, at least the chance to escape with my life and be hunted down. Perhaps you'll never find me and my char will walk into a mek, or I'll get caught and stabbed in the back. Never know, could lead a prosperous life and enslave you.

http://www.zalanthas.org/gdb/index.php/topic,30139.0.html *
*Not your typical slave role.  This has nothing to do with the rest of this post, but this role is open, and you don't have to special app:  it is a staff-sponsored role.  You e-mail the staff directly about it.


There are slave roles open, but most apped slave roles are within noble Houses or among the Templarate.

Slavery in Zalanthas is interesting, as is the social structure that has created it.  There exist three major noble Houses that deal entirely in slavery--both the breeding, training, and sale of them.  "Slavers?"  Yes, these Houses also are occasionally given recalcitrant prisoners or perhaps they capture new slaves and struggle to retrain them.  The better trained and loyal a slave is, the more valuable the slave is--and of course, the more unique skills they possess, the more valuable they are as a tradeable commodity.

In recent memory, I can name two instances where people were enslaved.  In both cases, it was a noble house or the templarate that was involved in the enslavement process.  In both cases, proceedings with those PCs had progressed so far that the only options were enslavement or death.

What makes someone a slave, in general?

The powers that be determine whether someone is a slave or not.  If you are Joe Shmoe raider and you "capture" someone with a few of your raider buddies, the better option would be to turn your captured person over to the closest slaving House, and sell them for a profit.  Depending on the city, there may be different proceedings for this.  If you raid and capture someone and make them your own slave without the blessing of the "powers that be" in either city (or even possibly Luir's) you could run into significant problems.  The fastest way to tell if someone is a slave:

--They wear a collar.
--They are a mul.

If you are a free mul, in the vast majority of cases, you are free because you escaped.  Muls are commonly recaptured.  If you say your slave is a slave, they would need a collar.  If they have no collar, other people may not recognize your slave as a slave.  If they do have a collar, people usually expect to see the colors of Winrothol or Borsail or Kasix on the slave.  This would imply that it has been sold to some independent group (your group of raiders, perhaps).  If the colors are different, it usually implies that the slave is the property of another noble House, whichever one that would be.

I'm not saying PCs owning a PC slave is impossible.
I'm not saying raiding and enslaving a PC is impossible.
I'm just pointing out some areas that I see some inaccuracies.  Unless you stay out of either city entirely, the major city-states are the powers that determine who is a slave and who is not.
Title: Re: You know what I want?
Post by: BlackMagic0 on March 27, 2008, 10:57:08 AM
I've been enslaved on past PCs.  ;D

I must say that some of the PCs were not to fond of it and the rest were like "Bah.. Could be worst.."! I enjoyed all of the enslavement PCs that I had very much.. and it was PC to PC enslave, no special application, just.. "Hey.. You.. Yah my bitch now."  8)

I miss the slave PCs.  :'(
Title: Re: You know what I want?
Post by: Elgiva on March 27, 2008, 01:30:17 PM
Quote from: Xio on March 27, 2008, 10:29:29 AM
Quote from: Ghost on March 27, 2008, 09:37:09 AM
Quote from: Xio on March 27, 2008, 04:19:02 AM
Shoot I wish I could play a slave. I've tried a few times to get into slaves roles only to get shot down with the 'We fear it will be to constricting and simply boring for you' I understand and accept such concerns.

I believe you can special app if it is something you want to play.

I've tried spec apps. That's what I've been told. Never spec apped when they were LOOKING for slaves is my problem I think. Randomly asking for a slave or gladiator is a no-no apparently *shrugs* and I'm always deep in a char when they're looking. Don't wanna spec app and tie up that slave slot if by some wild chance my char lives past his next meal.

I tried to app and was told the same. I understand the concern, but seeing IMMs not approving spec. apps for slaves kind of makes me inclined to think IG enslaving is also not really that "great" either. I remember one of my characters took a part in enslaving a couple of PCs... and really, all of them suicided, stored, died or were killed for acting like fools (sometime I really got an impression they wish to be killed).

On the other side, if there is some noble/templar/enslaver who really -really- feels s/he could make the game fun for their slave and wishes to try to play a master, I think they should let the IMMs know. Apparently, there -are- people interested in playing slaves, the problem is to put the right ends together, eh?
Title: Re: You know what I want?
Post by: LittleLostThief on March 27, 2008, 02:40:14 PM
A lot of people have the wrong idea about slavery in the first place.  They let their real world concepts interfere with the understanding of slaves in the game.

1)  A major part of the population are slaves.

2)  99.997% of slaves WANT to be slaves, and wouldn't dream of escaping.

Being a slave means that someone is taking care of you.  It means that you have a place to sleep that isn't a midden heap in an alley.  It means that someone is providing food and water for your continued survival.  All in all, though slaves are below commoners on the social rung, they've got it a lot nicer than some of them.  Most commoners down on their luck might even try to become slaves, just for their continued survival.  And they'd be fucking ecstatic to be so.
Title: Re: You know what I want?
Post by: Marauder Moe on March 27, 2008, 02:46:54 PM
Quote from: LittleLostThief on March 27, 2008, 02:40:14 PM2)  99.997% of slaves WANT to be slaves, and wouldn't dream of escaping.
QFT.

Most Zalanthan slaves (95-99%) were either born slaves or sold into it at a very young age.  The dominant method of enslavement is psychological conditioning (or simply the offer of reliable food and safety) rather than physical movement restriction or pervasive law enforcement.

That's why captured PC slaves are so rare and/or unplayable.  You can't quickly condition an adult PC enough that you can be reasonably certain they won't just rip off the collar and run away.  The only way to really enslave them is cages and shackles, which then make that PC entirely dependent on their master(s) for interaction.  In some clans and in some circumstances this can work, but for most players it will not.
Title: Re: You know what I want?
Post by: Tisiphone on March 27, 2008, 03:04:25 PM
All of which translates to: raid the tribals and take their babies.

GREAT occupation for an "independent" opportunistic raiding group that's large enough. Sell'm off to the templarate for some pretty cash.

Contract yourself out to recapture escaped slaves. There are usually at least a couple of these running around somewhere.

So on and so forth.
Title: Re: You know what I want?
Post by: Mood on March 27, 2008, 03:13:31 PM
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Slave_rebellion

QuoteA slave rebellion is an armed uprising by slaves. Slave rebellions have occurred in nearly all societies that practice slavery, and are amongst the most feared events for slave owners. Famous historic slave rebellions have been led by Denmark Vesey; the Roman slave Spartacus; the thrall Tunni who rebelled against the Swedish king Ongenþeow, a rebellion that needed Danish assistance to be quelled; Madison Washington during the Creole case in 19th century America; and Granny Nanny of the Maroons who rebelled against the British in Jamaica.

Now, while some things might be different between Zalanthan and Earth slavery, I'd hardly say that such a high percentage are happy to be slaves.
Title: Re: You know what I want?
Post by: Marauder Moe on March 27, 2008, 03:25:06 PM
Slave rebellions don't end all slavery.  Zalanthas (Allanak) has already seen a major slave rebellion too.


But anyway, it's not about being happy, it's about fearing the free world more than you fear slave life.  Life in Allanak sucks in general, and yet you still don't have lots of people just leaving and living out in the desert.  Likewise, life as a slave sucks, but you still don't have lots of slaves tossing off their collars and going to starve in streets.
Title: Re: You know what I want?
Post by: staggerlee on March 27, 2008, 03:26:46 PM
http://www.armageddon.org/general/slavery.html

The doc on slavery is very long and very detailed.  Actually it should resolve a lot of the questions this thread is bringing up. 
It doesn't clarify whether it's acceptable to capture pc slaves, but it does discuss playing a slave or a slave owner and detail how most people would react to being a slave, as well as where they come from, etc.
Title: Re: You know what I want?
Post by: Mood on March 27, 2008, 03:29:02 PM
I agree with you on most counts, but I have trouble believing that 99% (or any number close to it) want to be slaves. History (both in game, and in real life) has shown us differently.
Title: Re: You know what I want?
Post by: staggerlee on March 27, 2008, 03:36:36 PM
Quote from: Slavery Documentation
Slavery, the legal ownership of one being by another, is a fact of life on Zalanthas. Most inhabitants of the world accept this as the way things work; very few would see any injustice in it.


Quote from:  The docs again.
While some slaves may wish to escape bondage, many will not. The life of a slave is, in many ways, actually better than that of a starving beggar or scavenger. Slaves are effectively guaranteed food, water, and lodgings in return for loyalty, obedience, and hard work. The only main difference between a slave and a free citizen, in many cases, is that the slave does not have personal freedom to do as he/she wishes; he/she is subject to the will of the owner.

Seriously, it's all in there.  Give it a read.
Title: Re: You know what I want?
Post by: Marauder Moe on March 27, 2008, 03:42:27 PM
Again, I didn't say they want to be slaves.  I said they'd rather be slaves than starving.  Both suck, but one is pretty clearly better than the other (though maybe not to our culture where freedom is very highly valued, to the point where perhaps death is preferable).

EDIT: well maybe I did quote that they want to be slaves... but still, I hope my point is clear.
Title: Re: You know what I want?
Post by: Tarx on March 27, 2008, 03:43:05 PM
While using real world historical figures and history is good to do to give perspective, there are some key differences that make this much different in Zalanthas.

1. This was tried once before and met with brutal (and I mean seriously brutal) consequences.

Quote from: Zalanthas Historical Documentation
1394
The joint forces of the Clear Waters Oasis tribe and the Ironsword clan attack Allanak's obsidian mine, managing to free the slaves. Thrain Ironsword dies in the battle along with several templars. After the attack the Clear Waters Oasis tribe, joined by a horde of former slaves, lay siege to Allanak. During this time, Tektolnes is mysteriously absent.
1395
Exactly one year after the beginning of the siege of Allanak, Tektolnes reappears in the guise of a dragon and breathes death upon the sieging army - the army ceases to exist. Over the course of the next few years, a temple is built near the entrance of the city, in which the newly formed white-robe templarate preach the worship of He Who Rescued Us, the Mighty Dragon Tektolnes.

2.  Zalanthas has magick, and two very powerful established power structures that use every means necessary to stay in power.
3.  Many slaves have it better than commoners, which is hilariously ironic.  In the north, there is a caste system that specifically says slaves have a caste, and high-ranked slaves can be regarded as more socially powerful than many commoners.  I'm not as familiar with slavery in the south, unfortunately.  Slavery in the majority of cases means:
---You have worth.
---You are cared for, fed, and given things to do.
---You're given gear and clothing.
---You have guaranteed employment for life.
This certainly sounds better than the majority of commoners.

Maybe not 99% of slaves want to be slaves.  Maybe it's lower than that.  It's a high percentage, though.
Speaking from a Tuluki point of view, and pointing at documentation that supports this:
QuoteNobles and Commoners:
One of the important keys to noble/commoner roleplay is to remember not to carry attitudes over from real life. On Armageddon, the vast majority of Tuluki commoners, who live and die by the mercy of the Sun King, firmly believe that nobles are nobles because they're better. The same holds true for the nobles, who assume their privileged position is correct because they are of better blood and finer material than a commoner. This attitude is reinforced by their benefits: literacy, which acquires near-mystical dimensions in an illiterate society; vast wealth; social status; and freedom from most of the laws of the city.
This documentation only applies to nobles and commoners, but it stands to reason that other facets of society have similar views about caste.
Title: Re: You know what I want?
Post by: Southie on March 27, 2008, 04:28:43 PM
The slaves that don't want to be slaves are probably the slaves in very brutal and low-value occupations: common labor slaves, gladiator slaves, latrine slaves, etc. These slaves are also probably the worst treated and the most likely to have been forced into slavery rather than raised as slaves.

Brutal mistreatment from a master will probably also increase the liklihood that a slave wants to escape.

But most of the "valuable" slaves, those born into slavery and given extensive conditioning and training (Borsail/Winrothol/Kasix slaves) are probably perfectly happy with their lot in life. I think 99% of those slaves not wanting to escape actually makes sense.
Title: Re: You know what I want?
Post by: Salt Merchant on March 27, 2008, 06:22:53 PM
Quote from: LittleLostThief on March 27, 2008, 02:40:14 PM
2)  99.997% of slaves WANT to be slaves, and wouldn't dream of escaping.

I think that you underestimate the value of freedom. Something that people have fought for throughout all of history. Even Rome, which was pretty liberal in its treatment of slaves, had its revolts. In fact, I remember there being a slave revolt in Allanak once too and even Allanak being beseiged by mining slaves together with Ironsword dwarves.

As for slaves being too valuable to abuse, there are endless instances of abuse throughout history too. People being worked to death in mines without proper sustenance is one example.

In any society that has such a contempt for human life as Allanak, it would be strange indeed to find slaves pleased with their lot. The common slave would get the worst of foods and the worst of living conditions and the constant feel of the lash on their backs.

If slaves had it better than commoners, then commoners would sell their offspring into slavery.

Muls would be coddled, but only because of their extreme value. Not everyone.
Title: Re: You know what I want?
Post by: Only He Stands There on March 27, 2008, 08:45:36 PM
I respectfully disagree. No society in the world has been remotely like Armageddon's.

There have never been such disproportional gaps between the poor and the rich than there are in Zalanthas. Remember, in the Zalanthan city-states, every single day at least one noble bathes, and every single day I'd imagine a dozen people in the same city-state die of dehydration.

Slaves don't have to worry about where they're going to get their next drink, how they're going to provide for their family, what they'll do if they get robbed. They have an easy life, compared to the "free" peoples of Zalanthas.

Remember that PCs are not indicative of typical Zalanthan life. Your typical Zalanthan is dirt fucking poor and desperate for that next drink of water, bite to eat, and month of rent.

As for "if slaves had it better than commoners, then commoners would sell their offspring into slavery..."

Commoners DO. PCs DON'T.
Title: Re: You know what I want?
Post by: Wish on March 28, 2008, 04:38:20 AM
If I was a slave who was beaten every day and screamed at by cruel masters as I toiled upon the unforgiving fields beneath the boiling sun, I might think about escaping.  Maybe at night as I lay exhausted in the heavily guarded slave barracks, I would think to myself, "I bet things are better in tuluk/allanak/red storm/luirs/cenyr.  I bet I could do it. I bet I could escape."  But the next morning, rudely kicked out of bed by my satanic owners, I would return to the fields, to be worked again to the bone.  People are reluctant to change their situation, even if they might obtain a better one.  Especially if they have been raised to it their entire life.

And if I was a slave who was ensconced in luxury, dressed in silks, pampered (likely by other slaves), and treated better than 99% of commoners, I definitely wouldn't consider escaping.  If I was a slave like that, I would be ecstatic, and wear my diamond-studded collar with pride.  Even if, for some reason, I wanted to leave the wonderful nirvana of my existence, the above still applies.  Most people are reluctant to change their situation, especially if it means moving from a good life to an incredibly poor one.
Title: Re: You know what I want?
Post by: Yam on March 28, 2008, 04:52:02 AM
Slaves who are captured rarely wish to be slaves.


Slaves who are born slaves into houses are another beast altogether.


Title: Re: You know what I want?
Post by: Rindan on March 29, 2008, 09:09:17 AM
Quote from: LittleLostThief on March 27, 2008, 04:03:25 AM
Everyone plays to have fun.  The general consensus is that getting enslaved against your will kills that fun.

Dying is part of the game, and something that you can't really argue with.  Being forced to play something you don't want to apparently crosses a line.

Would you like it if I apped a character for you, down to the starting location, and forced you to play it?  Probably not.

Is it a little unrealistic?  Just a tad.  As a slaver though, you might be able to get away with "OOC:  Consent to being enslaved?", and if they say no, kill them instead.  After all, they were pretty weak, malnourished, and their teeth were obviously rotting out.  They wouldn't have made good slaves anyway.

Playing a slave isn't always that much fun anyway.  It always comes down to needing to be on when your master is, at least sometimes, and that isn't always possible.  Being randomly sold IC'ly to the highest bidder might not exactly facilitate that kind of relationship.

If you don't like being enslaved, just store the character.  It really is that simple.  If you don't like storing characters... well tough.  I don't like having my characters killed because someone in power thought that it was OOCly wrong to enslave people. 

If tomorrow my character was smacked down by some Templar for some crime, I would happily take being enslaved over having my character killed.  The worst that can possibly happen is that I am bored to tears and I just store the character, which is absolutely no worse than dying.  At best, I have a new found goal of freedom, an interesting social situation where all my friends need to awkwardly deal with the fact that I am now a slave, and an in to the politics of whatever group I get assigned to.

Will a small time group of PC slavers work out well?  Probably not.  Enslaving Allanaki citizens is likely to get you spanked by the templerate.  In fact, getting the Templerate to reconize the people you capture as slaves is then buying them from you is likely to be fraught with problems.  On top of that, if you are snatching tribals than they are almost certainly totally unfit for being anything other than labor slaves.  Getting snatched and sold to the obsidian mines sounds like an an absolutely awesome way to have a character come to an end, but it is basically a forced store.  It is like dying, but you have a far more awesome story to tell people about years later than the usual, "yeah, a scrab whacked me on the head".

Personally, I hope that people in power don't look at enslave as some sort of evil taboo.  Enslave someone, throw a collar on them, and tell them that they are now your servant.  If they run, eh, they run and you are rid of the criminal.  If they store, well, the other alternative was to simply kill them.  On the other hand, other people would look upon it as a golden opportunity for character development and a great alternative to getting subdue killed by half-giant soldiers.
Title: Re: You know what I want?
Post by: Maybe42or54 on March 29, 2008, 10:17:31 AM
Or I would see it as a great -avenue- that you could use to kill your enslaver, if they trust you too much.
Title: Re: You know what I want?
Post by: Dalmeth on March 29, 2008, 01:13:51 PM
Ya know... some slavers might offer their victims the opportunity to buy themselves out.  It's kinda like raiding, but with a longer period of interaction with the raiders.  All they really have to do is get a license from the local authorities saying that anyone they bring in as a slave is just that, a slave.  At least until they remove some sort of identifying marker.
Title: Re: You know what I want?
Post by: Xio on March 29, 2008, 01:21:25 PM
and just because you're a slave doesn't mean suddenly you can't contact ppl anymore. If you have no friends to contact and launch a rescue attempt if you can't free yourself, then well...that sucks. Simply enslaving that guy over there who looks to tired to even stand could turn into a fun RPT with 20 people kicking down your door and shooting you full of arrows. Imms should consider that aspect of it, imo.
Title: Re: You know what I want?
Post by: a strange shadow on March 29, 2008, 02:11:45 PM
What Rindan said.
Title: Re: You know what I want?
Post by: Dalmeth on March 29, 2008, 02:58:52 PM
Quote from: Xio on March 29, 2008, 01:21:25 PM
and just because you're a slave doesn't mean suddenly you can't contact ppl anymore. If you have no friends to contact and launch a rescue attempt if you can't free yourself, then well...that sucks. Simply enslaving that guy over there who looks to tired to even stand could turn into a fun RPT with 20 people kicking down your door and shooting you full of arrows. Imms should consider that aspect of it, imo.

Well, there's also your friends getting the money to buy you off.

Just imagine the fun if they decided not to let you free afterward.
Title: Re: You know what I want?
Post by: Silverfaune on April 07, 2008, 03:40:38 PM
Just to pitch in, I would really find the danger of being caught by slavers while out exploring (or even wandering a dark alley) much more enticing (as it would lead to some really intense rp and some fun directions I didn't plan for my character) than say, being eaten by halflings, gored by carru, killed outright for my water/clothes/stamp collection by someone with a bow who doesn't want to chance rping with me before they kill me... in fact it sounds much more fun than about 99% of the chance encounters with "baddies" that I can think of.  At the very least, it'd be nicer to be bludgeoned and wake up in shackles or have someone put mercy on and ask for my consent so I have the choice to serve in some fashion, instead of dying (or pretend to serve and deal with the risks later!).  As a supposedly mature adult I think that having that choice is at least as viable as having the choice over whether or not I want to rp torture or rape...
Title: Re: You know what I want?
Post by: Maso on April 07, 2008, 04:30:19 PM
Quote from: Only He Stands There on March 27, 2008, 08:45:36 PM
I respectfully disagree. No society in the world has been remotely like Armageddon's.

I disagree with that. There are many societies in present day and through history that both mirror the heat, dehydration, poverty and wealth of Arm. Except the gap is more so. It was probably more like 100 nobles bath a day while 1000 commoners die. Anyway, I just got back from South India - and I thought I was lost in Zalanthas for part of it. I've never first hand experienced poverty like that.

As for slavery: in my mind conditioned slaves would be content, born slaves they would usually grow to respect and love their masters rather than resent them. A captured slave would be resentful when captured but may find himself conditioned by the better living conditions if they are so. If he's enslaved and forced into a shit life, then his will just needs to be broken. (I've literally just finished reading two historically factual but fictional books, the first is the Sword and Scimitar which addresses the issue of the slave trade and the conditioning of captured slaves, and the second Imperium which is from the perspective of a Roman senators slave (born into slavery), both very good reads!)
Title: Re: You know what I want?
Post by: alger on April 08, 2008, 03:19:07 AM
Come lets go make a group of baby snatchers!  We go around, mudsexing/raping, then wait 9 months then steal the baby and sell them as slaves.

It will be like harvesting.  We will make a route to our regime.  On the first month we will sex it up in the salt flats as we raid the tribes there, then we will move west and go clock wise across the known world.  We move every 1 month and have 9 stops, after that we go back to our original spot.  As we bring sexy back we also steal the seeds that we have planted nine months ago.

We will call ourselves... hmmm... Bangbrothers.